Perspectives, note 1. September 2026. 8 minute read.

The one-way ratchet: why the tax bill grows with a small cap but never shrinks with it

For a growing company, a large share of what it pays the state is levied on revenue, value added and payroll, not on profit. Those charges rise with every step up. When the business has to step back, they do not fall on their own, and the steps needed to reduce them are themselves slow and costly.

Ask the CFO of a listed small cap what kills companies of their size and the answers are familiar: running out of cash, losing a key customer, a financing that arrives too late. Tax is rarely on the list. It should be.

The problem is not the headline rate of corporate income tax. It is the structure of the whole bill. It is built to follow a company up and not to follow it down. Growth raises it quickly. Contraction reduces it slowly, if at all. And the tools a company uses to adjust (cutting costs, reducing headcount, restructuring debt) carry their own price. We call this the one-way ratchet.

The examples below are drawn mainly from France, with comparisons from the UK and Germany. The pattern is European.

On the way up

Growth is taxed before it is profitable

A company that doubles its revenue while still breaking even pays little corporate income tax. It does not pay little tax. A long list of levies is assessed on activity rather than on earnings.

Payroll. Employer social contributions are the largest single line for most growing companies. In France they are among the highest in Europe. In the UK, employer National Insurance rose to 15% in April 2025 and the threshold at which it starts was cut to £5,000 a year. Every hire made to capture growth carries this charge from its first month, long before that hire pays for itself.

Value added. France’s CVAE is levied on value added once turnover passes €500,000. Its abolition has been announced, postponed and rescheduled several times. Under the current timetable the top rate stays at 0.28% in 2026 and 2027 and the tax disappears only in 2030.

Revenue and property. The C3S solidarity contribution applies to turnover above €19 million. The CFE is levied on business premises. In Germany, trade tax adds back a quarter of financing costs above €200,000, so a leveraged company can owe trade tax in a year when it barely breaks even.

What moves with what

ChargeRises withFalls when
Employer social chargesEvery hire, every raiseHeadcount is cut, slowly and at a cost
Value-added and turnover leviesRevenue growthRevenue falls, even when margin is negative
Property-based taxesNew sites, larger premisesLeases end or sites close
Corporate income taxProfitProfit falls, but loss relief is capped

The thresholds

Growth arrives in steps, and so does the bill

Tax and regulatory obligations are not smooth curves. They switch on at thresholds. In France, crossing 50 employees brings a fuller works council, mandatory employee profit-sharing and a series of reporting and consultation duties. The 2019 PACTE law softened the blow: a threshold now only counts once it has been crossed for five consecutive years. But it still counts, and it cannot be uncrossed by shrinking for a year.

Turnover thresholds work the same way. The CVAE starts at €500,000, the C3S at €19 million. Each step up the stairs adds a permanent layer of cost and administration that was designed with larger companies in mind.

On the way down

When the business turns, the bill does not

A contract is delayed, a product launch slips, a market softens. Revenue falls by a fifth. Profit, which was thin, disappears. What happens to the tax bill?

Corporate income tax falls to zero, as it should. Almost everything else stays. Social charges follow payroll, and payroll is the hardest cost to move. Levies on value added and turnover keep running on the revenue that remains. Property taxes stay until premises are given up.

The relief available for the bad year is also limited. In France, tax losses carried forward can only offset the first €1 million of profit in full, and half of any profit above that. Losses can be carried back only one year, and only up to €1 million. The deduction for interest is capped at the higher of €3 million or 30% of tax EBITDA, so when EBITDA falls the deductible share of interest falls with it, exactly when the company is most leveraged.

The result is a timing problem more than a rate problem. Cash leaves the company for tax on the way up, before growth has paid for itself. Cash leaves again on the way down, because the charges do not adjust. And when the company recovers, the caps on loss relief mean it starts paying corporate tax well before it has recovered what it lost.

The cost of adjusting

Adjusting is itself expensive

The obvious answer is to cut costs. For a small cap, that is where the ratchet bites hardest.

People. In France, a company with 50 or more employees that plans ten or more redundancies within 30 days must put in place a job-protection plan (PSE), with consultation, administrative validation, and support and severance commitments. The savings arrive months after the decision. The cost arrives first.

Debt. Renegotiating debt means advisers, lawyers and often a court-supervised procedure. A debt write-off is generally taxable income for the borrower, with only partial relief for waivers granted within formal proceedings. The company can end up owing tax on the relief it was given.

Disclosure. A listed company must tell the market. The share price reacts on the day of the announcement. The savings show up quarters later. In between, raising equity becomes more expensive and more dilutive.

A private company can often adjust quietly. A listed small cap adjusts in public, under procedure, and pays for each step before it benefits.

The tax system taxes growth in cash, taxes contraction in cash, and taxes recovery early. A company that funds all three from operations is betting that nothing will go wrong.

What it means

What boards and CFOs can do

None of this can be avoided. It can be planned for.

  1. 1Model the downside with the tax lines that do not move. A base case that shows corporate tax falling to zero in a bad year understates the cash need. Run the stress case with payroll charges, turnover levies and property taxes held where they are.
  2. 2Treat thresholds as decisions, not accidents. Know which headcount and turnover thresholds are ahead, what each will cost, and whether the growth that crosses them justifies it.
  3. 3Budget for the cost of adjusting before you need to. If a restructuring would take six months and cost a year of savings upfront, that money has to exist before the decision, not after.
  4. 4Match the shape of financing to the shape of the risk. Fixed repayment schedules and tight covenants take cash out at the worst moment. Capital drawn in tranches, sized to a milestone and repayable in more than one form, gives the company room to absorb a bad quarter without starting a restructuring.
  5. 5Arrange flexibility while it is cheap. The best time to put a standby facility in place is when the company does not need it. The terms available on the landing are always better than the terms available on the way down.

Tax rules described are as understood at September 2026 and summarised for general discussion. They change frequently and depend on each company’s circumstances. This note is not tax, legal or investment advice.

Nothing on this site is an offer of securities or investment advice.

© 2026 Palier Capital